Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant
Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Catering Menu
  • About
  • More
    • Home
    • Menu
    • Catering Menu
    • About
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Catering Menu
  • About

The Homemade Taste of Italy in Freeport

Homemade sopressatta on a wooden cutting board with a glass if wine in Freeport, NY

Atlantic Pizzeria is not your average neighborhood pizza joint.

Beyond the eclectic decor -- brick arches, ceramic tile, walls covered with framed images of blues musicians and memorabilia, Old Hollywood and classic rock -- the picture-perfect pizzas are displayed above a case full of artichokes, delicate fried zucchini sticks, bright green broccoli rabe. Most remarkable are the salumi (Italian cured sausages): soppressata, both hot and sweet, and capicola, all of which are made by Teresa Napoli. Teresa and Rocco Napoli bought Atlantic Pizzeria in 1988, a few years after they returned to Long Island from a decade-long sojourn in their ancestral home, the Calabrian town of Marina di Gioiosa Jonica. Almost thirty years later, their son Frank runs the store, and his primary responsibility is to support and build upon his mother’s artistry. Frank proudly recounts how when a family would slaughter a pig back in Calabria, they would call upon Teresa to supervise the butchering and make the most out of every part -- the hind legs for ham, the loins for roasts, the shoulder for various salumi. Here on Long Island, Teresa works with American pork; other ingredients -- fennel, hot pepper -- are sent from Calabria, and the small amount of wine called for is made deeply unctuous. “I put my mom’s salumi up against anyone’s,” Frank says.

 “Not everyone appreciates it, but some people do and that’s what keeps us alive.”

Homemade sopressatta hanging

Mom's Soppressata

The perfect addition to holiday and party antipasto platters!

Freshly prepared sausage and pepper rolls right out of the oven at Atlantic Pizzeria in Freeport, NY

Always Fresh

From specialty rolls and slices, to delectable entrees- everything is always fresh and homemade! 

Connect With Us

Copyright © 2025 Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

DeclineAccept